Police chiefs are highly visible public leaders, yet the people evaluating candidates must often make decisions before they can observe how those candidates will lead. Credentials become signals, but some signals may carry more weight than others.
About Gordon Abner

Gordon Abner is an Associate Professor at the LBJ School of Public Affairs at the University of Texas at Austin and is the corresponding author of this study. He received a Joint PhD in Public Policy from Indiana University-Bloomington. His primary research interests are in the areas of employee morale and organizational performance in the public sector broadly, as well as in policing specifically.
About the authors
- Gordon Abner (Associate Professor, LBJ School of Public Affairs, University of Texas at Austin)
- Emily Mee (Assistant Professor, Hugo Wall School of Public Affairs, Wichita State University)
Read the article
Read the full research article, “What signals police leadership quality to the public? A look at evidence-based policing and professional standards,” published in the Journal of Experimental Criminology in 2026.
View the publicationWe are grateful to the authors for advancing evidence on public expectations of police leadership and for referencing Evidano, formerly AILYZE, as part of a human-validated qualitative triangulation process.
Run this analysis on your own data
Evidano codes documents, interviews, survey responses and spreadsheets with AI, with your judgment in control at every step.
This research elsewhere on Evidano
Related published research
Other published studies and evaluations that used Evidano on comparable material.
- Published research2026

ENAP and UBC used AI-assisted qualitative coding on 39,788 federal survey comments
A peer-reviewed, open-access study coded 39,788 open-ended comments against a predefined thematic grid, then manually verified a random 15% sample.
39,788 open-ended comments coded
Public Personnel Management (SAGE), 2026, open access
- Published research2024

William & Mary’s AI thematic analysis of 19,000+ open-ended responses from 3,443 adults
AI-assisted thematic analysis of 12 open-ended questions in batches of 150 responses, each run three times and verified quote by quote by a human researcher.
3,443 participants in the study
Research report by the William & Mary Center for Gifted Education for the Mensa Foundation, May 2024 (W&M ScholarWorks)
- Published research2024

Monash University study trialled AI thematic analysis to cross-check its themes
See how doctoral education researchers trialled Evidano for thematic analysis, with human researchers leading every interpretation.
23 doctoral writers’ responses analysed, from 29 recruited
Studies in Educational Evaluation, vol. 83, 101379 (Elsevier, 2024), open access
