Evidano home
Doctoral dissertation published by the University of La VerneResearch SpotlightUniversity of La Verne

Research Spotlight: How Engineering Managers in Manufacturing Work to Keep Their Engineers

Evidano10 min read
Gustavo Guevara, Doctor of Education, LaFetra College of Education, University of La Verne

Picture an engineering manager at a U.S. manufacturer who wants to keep a capable engineer. Some of what shapes that engineer’s decision, such as pay, working conditions and company policy, may be decided well above the manager’s level. Other things are part of the manager’s everyday practice: whether the engineer’s work is engaging, whether leadership communicates clearly, and whether there is a visible path to grow and advance. Voluntary turnover among engineers is costly for manufacturers, so knowing which of these levers managers actually use, and how, is a practical question as much as an academic one.

That question is at the center of “A Qualitative Case Study Exploring Retention Strategies Employed by Engineering Managers in the Manufacturing Sector,” Gustavo Guevara’s 2026 Doctor of Education dissertation at the University of La Verne’s LaFetra College of Education. Starting from the observation that there is limited research on retention specifically within manufacturing engineering, the qualitative case study explored the strategies that engineering managers in U.S. manufacturing organizations use to reduce voluntary employee turnover. The data came from semi-structured interviews and document review with purposefully sampled engineering managers, and were coded and analyzed through thematic analysis with the support of Evidano, then known as AILYZE.

We spoke with Gustavo Guevara, whose doctoral research was completed in the LaFetra College of Education at the University of La Verne, to learn more about what engineering managers described, how he approached the analysis, and what the findings mean for manufacturing organizations trying to keep their engineers.

About the dissertation

Research question

What strategies do engineering managers in U.S. manufacturing organizations use to reduce voluntary turnover among engineers? Guevara looked at retention from the position of managers, who play a direct role in it, and read their accounts through two theoretical lenses: Herzberg’s two-factor theory and transformational leadership theory.

Key finding

The findings showed that reasons for retention are multifaceted rather than driven by a single lever. Engineers are more likely to stay when they are engaged, when leadership communicates clearly, and when there are clear growth opportunities. The dissertation recommends that organizations formalize opportunities for growth and advancement, foster a culture of transparency, and train managers on effective leadership strategies. The main caveat is one of perspective: the study reflects how managers see retention, not engineers’ own reasons for staying or leaving, and its findings come from a qualitative case study in one sector.

Why this research matters

Pay is an obvious place to start when thinking about why people stay in a job, but it is not the whole picture. Herzberg’s two-factor theory, one of the two frameworks behind the study, separates factors such as working conditions, pay and policies, which prevent dissatisfaction, from factors such as growth, recognition and meaningful work, which encourage people to stay. Transformational leadership theory adds a focus on what managers do: communicating a vision, building trust and coaching employees, practices the dissertation treats as a lens on how leadership can reduce turnover.

Guevara’s study makes that discussion concrete in a setting where, as the dissertation notes, research on retention is limited: manufacturing engineering. Rather than asking what should keep engineers in theory, it asks managers what they actually do. Its answer, that retention is multifaceted, points beyond pay to engagement, communication and growth, which are part of a manager’s day-to-day work. For HR leaders and engineering managers, that offers a research-based view of retention grounded in managers’ own accounts. Gustavo Guevara explained what drew him to the topic: “No matter which organization I was part of, engineers never stayed. That matters, because when engineers leave, there are no senior people to guide the next generation in how to innovate within the organization, and it weakens the perception of how valuable engineers are. I’ve also been in organizations where I felt unhappy and wanted to leave, but I never understood why. I focused on managers because they were usually at the center of why people left. After studying leadership, I realized how heavily managers influence an engineer’s satisfaction, and I wanted to see what they were doing right and what they were doing wrong. When I move into a leadership role, I want to make sure my team is satisfied, so I can build a truly skilled department that keeps the organization innovating, and an environment where everyone is happy and comfortable sharing ideas.”

Key findings from the dissertation

The analysis looked for patterns in leadership practices, communication approaches and development strategies tied to retention. Three findings stand out because they point to practices within a manager’s reach.

  • Engaged engineers are more likely to stay. The dissertation identifies engagement as one of the conditions under which engineers stay. Read through Herzberg’s two-factor theory, which guided the analysis, retention depends on more than avoiding dissatisfaction with pay and conditions: growth, recognition and meaningful work also encourage engineers to stay.
  • Clear communication from leadership matters. Engineers are more likely to stay when leadership communicates clearly. Transformational leadership theory, the study’s second lens, draws attention to how managers communicate a vision, build trust and coach employees, and the dissertation recommends that organizations foster a culture of transparency.
  • Growth opportunities need to be visible. Engineers are more likely to stay when there are clear growth opportunities. The dissertation recommends that organizations formalize opportunities for growth and advancement and train managers on effective leadership strategies.

Taken together, the findings show that no single factor explains why engineers stay. Retention depends on several conditions at once, and engagement, communication and growth opportunities are each shaped in part by everyday management practice. Gustavo Guevara reflected on what stood out most: “What surprised me most was that most of the managers understood engineers are driven by money, yet some of them couldn’t do anything to keep or satisfy their engineers, mainly because of company policies and budgets. That told me company policy itself is another huge part of turnover, which aligned with the theories I used for my framework.”

Methods and research approach

Guevara used a qualitative case study design. Data were collected through semi-structured interviews and document review, using purposeful sampling of engineering managers working in manufacturing. The study was guided by Herzberg’s two-factor theory and the theory of transformational leadership. Herzberg’s model helped explain how working conditions, pay and policies prevent dissatisfaction, while growth, recognition and meaningful work encourage engineers to stay. Transformational leadership provided a lens for understanding how managers who communicate a vision, build trust and coach employees can contribute to lower turnover.

The interview and document data were coded and analyzed using thematic analysis with the support of Evidano, then known as AILYZE, to identify patterns in leadership practices, communication approaches and development strategies tied to retention. Combining interviews with document review gave the study more than one source of evidence on how managers approach retention.

The dissertation’s suggestions for future research also mark the study’s main limits. Future studies may expand the work by focusing on different sectors, or on engineers rather than management. As a qualitative case study of managers in one sector, it describes in depth the strategies managers report using, rather than measuring turnover rates.

Asked about the study’s participants and the limitations he noted, Gustavo Guevara said: “I interviewed five engineering managers from across the United States, working in different engineering sectors, and transcribed and reviewed the interviews. I noticed 2 main limitations. Only one of the five managers was a woman, so the study may not capture differences in the strategies male and female managers use. And because the participants came from several industries rather than one, the findings are broader than a single-industry study would produce. Manufacturing, for example, can be more intense than other engineering settings because of fast-moving KPIs, so a study focused on one industry could give a more precise picture of what happens there.”

How Evidano supported the research

The dissertation names Evidano, then known as AILYZE, in its abstract: “Data were coded and analyzed using thematic analysis with the support of AILYZE to identify patterns in leadership practices, communication approaches, and development strategies tied to retention.” This spotlight therefore describes Evidano as a tool that supported the coding and thematic analysis, not as the source of the study’s interpretation. The study’s design, its theoretical framing, and its conclusions and recommendations are the researcher’s own.

Asked which parts of the analysis Evidano supported and how he checked its output, he said: “Evidano helped me organize everything. What I liked was that it gave me straightforward themes, and I could easily trace where each theme came from and why it was chosen. But there was a lot of hidden meaning in some of the participants’ answers, so I had to go back and double-check that Evidano’s analysis matched the human behavior I was seeing. It organized the data, but I made sure everything made sense.”

Gustavo Guevara described how the tool fit into his analysis: “Evidano gave me clear themes I could trace back to the data, but participants’ answers often carried hidden meaning. While Evidano did all the heavy lifting I still had to make sure that the quotes I received were accurate.”

Broader implications

For manufacturers, the dissertation’s recommendations are practical: formalize opportunities for growth and advancement, foster a culture of transparency, and train managers on effective leadership strategies. They place part of the answer to engineer turnover in management practice, alongside pay and working conditions, and by including leadership training they treat managers’ own skills as part of a retention strategy.

For researchers, the study adds a manufacturing engineering case to retention research, a setting the dissertation describes as under-researched, and shows how established motivation and leadership theories can frame the analysis of managers’ accounts. Asked for his advice, Gustavo Guevara said: “Advocate for your engineers on pay and policy where you can, but focus on what’s within your control, keep them engaged, communicate openly and show them a clear path to grow. The manager has a direct influence on whether an engineer stays, so always be the manager you would want to have.”

It is equally important to be clear about what the study does not show. It captures managers’ perspectives rather than engineers’ own reasons for staying or leaving, and its findings come from a qualitative case study in one sector. It describes the strategies managers report using rather than testing whether a given strategy reduces turnover. The dissertation itself points to the next steps: studies in other sectors, and studies centered on engineers rather than management.

About Gustavo Guevara

Gustavo Guevara, Doctor of Education, LaFetra College of Education, University of La Verne

Gustavo Guevara completed his Doctor of Education (EdD) in the LaFetra College of Education at the University of La Verne in 2026. His doctoral research explored the strategies engineering managers in U.S. manufacturing organizations use to reduce voluntary turnover among engineers. He also holds a Master of Business Administration from the University of La Verne and a Bachelor of Science in Manufacturing Engineering from California State Polytechnic University, Pomona. He works full time as a Process Engineer at Louis Vuitton US Manufacturing and teaches part time as an engineering professor at Cal Poly Pomona and as a professor in the Doctor of Education program at the University of La Verne. He served in the United States Marine Corps and credits his wife, Savannah, and their two boys Gael and Luca with supporting him through his doctoral journey.

About the authors

  • Gustavo Guevara (LaFetra College of Education, University of La Verne, United States)

Read the article

Read the full dissertation, “A Qualitative Case Study Exploring Retention Strategies Employed by Engineering Managers in the Manufacturing Sector,” published in the University of La Verne ResearchWorks repository in 2026.

Full citation

Guevara, G. (2026). A qualitative case study exploring retention strategies employed by engineering managers in the manufacturing sector [Doctoral dissertation, University of La Verne]. University of La Verne ResearchWorks. researchworks.laverne.edu/esploro/outputs/doctoral/A-Qualitative-Case-Study-Exploring-Retention/991004382102806311

View the publication

We are grateful to Gustavo Guevara for his contribution to research on retaining engineers in manufacturing and for referencing Evidano, then known as AILYZE, as part of his research process.

Other published studies and evaluations that used Evidano on comparable material.